PRIVACY + SECURITY BLOG

News, Developments, and Insights

high-tech technology background with eyes on computer display

More on Identifying the TB Patient

Daniel Solove @danielsolove
Founder of TeachPrivacy
June 3, 2007

X-ray

I blogged the other day about the inappropriate disclosure of the TB patient’s identity. Over at Chronicles of Dissent, Dissent has an interesting post worth reading about the issue. He quotes Dr. Martin Cetron, Director of Division of Global Migration and Quarantine at CDC, who said: “I don’t think, publicly naming the individual, which we never do, has any advantage in [faciliating contacting individuals at risk of contracting TB from exposure to the patient], since this is not a disease that’s spread by casual interactions with the public.” Dissent writes:

Continue Reading

Identifying the TB Patient

Daniel Solove @danielsolove
Founder of TeachPrivacy
June 2, 2007

X-ray

The other day, I blogged about the TB patient who flew to Europe and back with the knowledge that he had a rare form of TB. The media had been reporting on the case for a while, and the man’s name was not identified until a day or two ago, when a number of stories began including his full name and photograph, as well as the name and photographs of the woman he married (including photos from his wedding).

Continue Reading

Can the TB Patient Be Sued?

Daniel Solove @danielsolove
Founder of TeachPrivacy
May 31, 2007

Gavel

I’ve been pondering whether the TB patient with the rare hard-to-treat form of the disease who flew on so many flights can be sued by those other passengers whom he may have exposed to the illness. From the New York Times:

Continue Reading

Anuj Desai on the Post Office and the First Amendment

Daniel Solove @danielsolove
Founder of TeachPrivacy
May 31, 2007

Post Office and Privacy

Professor Anuj Desai (U. Wisconsin Law School) has posted his forthcoming article, The Transformation of Statutes into Constitutional Law: How Early Post Office Policy Shaped Modern First Amendment Doctrine, on SSRN. Anuj’s paper is a fascinating history of the early Post Office and how statutory protection of letters influenced constitutional law. From the abstract:

Continue Reading

Should We Get Rid of the Law School In-Class Essay Exam?

Daniel Solove @danielsolove
Founder of TeachPrivacy
May 13, 2007

Law School Exam

I’ve long been unhappy with the typical law school exam format. The entire grade for the class is based on one 3-hour in-class essay exam. The problem with this format is that many students aren’t particularly adept at writing very quickly under immense time pressure. So the exam tests, in part, the ability to write quickly — a skill that is only of limited usefulness in the practice of law. In real life, lawyers don’t write briefs in 3-hour timed sessions. Law firms would be very unhappy if they did — first because the brief probably wouldn’t be that good and second because it would amount to a meager 3 billable hours!

Continue Reading

Can the First Amendment Serve as a Source of Criminal Procedure?

Daniel Solove @danielsolove
Founder of TeachPrivacy
April 10, 2007

Constitution First Amendment

Typically, when we think of the constitutional criminal procedure that regulates government information gathering, we think of the Fourth and Fifth Amendments. But many government investigations involve collecting information about speech, association, religion, and the consumption of ideas. The NSA surveillance of telephone calls, for example, involves speech. National Security Letters can be used to obtain information about association and the consumption of ideas. And so on.

Continue Reading

Orin Kerr on the Fourth Amendment

Daniel Solove @danielsolove
Founder of TeachPrivacy
March 25, 2007

Police

Anybody familiar with Fourth Amendment law knows that it is utterly incoherent. In his new paper, Four Models of Fourth Amendment Protection, my colleague, Orin Kerr (GW Law School) argues that this incoherence is actually a good thing. He attempts to sort out the muddle that currently exists in Fourth Amendment law into four models. From the abstract:

Continue Reading